PETER MOUGEY (1842-1908)
The E-Sylum (3/17/2024)
Book Content
PETER MOUGEY (1842-1908)
E-Sylum Feature Writer and American Numismatic Biographies author Pete Smith submitted this article on Cincinnati collector Peter Mougey. Thanks!-Editor
Peter Mougey was not well known as a coin collector. It was only after his death that the highquality of his collection was revealed.
Pierre Nicolaus Mougey was born in Cincinnati, Ohio, on February 23, 1841, the son of DesireMougey (1807-1879) and Felicite Clement Mougey (1815-1882). His parents came from Franceand were Ohio farmers. In numismatic references, his name only appears as Peter Mougey.
He was married in 1871 to Josephine Fieber (1848-1923) and had three sons and two daughters.
Mougey and his partner, F. M. Boyer were partners in Colter & Company wholesale grocers atSixth and Main streets in Cincinnati. They acquired the firm after the 1880 death of founderAaron A. Colter.
Peter Mougey joined the ANA in February 1893 as member 131. A few years later, he was listedas member number 47.
In 1901, Mougey was appointed to the board of directors of Provident Savings Bank and TrustCompany.
Mougey died of pneumonia after a brief illness on February 13, 1908, and is buried with his wifeand parents at Spring Grove Cemetery in Cincinnati, Ohio.
The Cincinnati Post reported on February 21, 1908:
When Probate Court Deputy Frank Behle opened the safety deposit vault of the late PeterMougey, head of Colter & Co., he found what is believed to be one of the finest private coincollections in the country.
The article went on to describe storage of coins in cotton-lined boxes filed in a heavy tin box.Mougey did not share his collection and showed coins only to his wife.
The Quad-City Times of Davenport, Iowa, had a report on September 7, 1910:
Mr. (Gilbert) Mougey of Davenport recently sold his father's collection to a New Yorkmillionaire for over $30,000. The New Yorker did not desire the entire Mougey collection, butwas anxious to secure certain coins in it in order to complete his own collection. Mr. Mougeynaturally declined to break up his complete collection and would not part with any part of itwithout the New Yorker purchasing it entirely. This he did.
He made a specialty of American coins, and at the time of his death was supposed to have themost finely preserved, though not the largest, collection of this sort in existence.
The article did not identify the New York millionaire but it was subsequently revealed to beWilliam H. Woodin. After selecting what he wanted, Woodin consigned the rest to Thomas Elderfor his sale of September 1, 2 & 3, 1910. The sale was timed to run just before the 1910 A.N.A.convention held at the American Numismatic Society in New York City.
Elder emphasized the quality of the collection:
The late Peter Mougey, Esqr., may be said to have been a numismatic seer, The perfectpreservation of practically every one of his coins proves that when, many years ago, hepurchased the pieces, he looked far into the future. He prized only those coins which werebeautifully preserved, only the ones that turn out to be the most valuable today. For this reasonalone, Mr. Mougey must be regarded as one of the wisest, if not. Indeed, the most far-sightedAmerican numismatist of his day.
The February 1911 issue of The Numismatist reported on the sale of his collection:
Many record prices for United States coins have been made in 1910, but especially remarkablehave been the prices which have been paid for certain varieties of the old-fashioned copper centsthat were issued from 1793 to 1857. These are now the highest priced series of coins in theworld, according to a statement recently made by one of America's leading numismatists.
The highest price ever paid for a cent was $340, which was paid for an uncirculated specimen ofa Liberty cap cent dated 1793 which was sold in this city last September. The former owner ofthe coin, the late Peter Mougey of Cincinnati, is said to have taken a trip from his home toPhiladelphia to secure this specimen.
This 1793 Liberty Cap Cent is now known as Sheldon-13 in a PCGS holder as MS-64+BN.
Thomas Elder produced more than a hundred tokens and medals. These were cataloguedoriginally by Thomas K. DeLorey in The Numismatist for June and July 1980. They were thenpublished as Thomas L. Elder A Catalogue of His Tokens and Medals.
DeLorey-13 was a medal Elder produced to commemorate his sale of the Mougey collection.This illustration is from the book.
Pete adds:
"I made an amusing discovery while browsing through the Elder sale catalog. Lot 879 was thefirst half disme listed but not dated. The description is clearly for a 1792 half disme. It sold for$36, the fourth highest price paid up to that time. The coin is in my notes but I had forgottenabout it. It is not in the 1792 census published in 1792: Birth of a Nation's Coinage because thecoin could not be identified from the partial plate in the catalog."